Dangerous Instrumentality Doctrine Preempted in Florida for Aircraft By Moody Law | Personal Injury Attorneys on March 18, 2010

Normally after an accident or injury, the owner of a dangerous instrumentality, such as a car, truck, bus, plane, boat, vessel, etc., has been held strictly liable for the negligence of the driver/operator.  The historical reason for this is that public policy of the State of Florida should not be able to escape liability for the incident just because he let someone else drive his vehicle.  All of us, including lawmakers, know that cars, boats, planes, etc. all have the propensity to cause serious injuries or death as they can all reach high speeds and offer relatively little protection against injury or death (when compared to walking or bicycling).  Again, this is the reason for making the owners of such vehicles responsible for the carnage that occurs on our roadways, skies, and waterways.  As such, owners must be accountable to make sure that their vehicles are maintained properly and that they think twice before they entrust their vehicles out to other people who might not drive with the same level of care.  A decision by the Second DCA (Vreeland v. Ferrer) recently held that the Federal Aviation Act, 49 U.S.C. sec. 44112 preempts the dangerous instrumentality doctrine in the State of Florida insofar as it would hold the owner or lessor of a civil aircraft liable for another's negligence committed when the owner or lessor was not in actual possession or control of the aircraft.  Essentially, in order for the injured person to hold the owner of civil aircraft liable, the injured person must show that the owner was actually at the controls of the plane as there is language in the decision about controlling the propellor.  As such, it is doubtful that an owner in one of the passenger seats of the plane without controls would not be preempted from liability.

Related to This

Daniel D. Moody, J.D., B.C.S.

Moody Law, P.A.

Moody Law was founded by Daniel D. Moody for the sole and exclusive purpose of representing the injured. Our main office is centrally located next to the Polk County Courthouse in Bartow, FL, serving Lakeland, Winter Haven, and all the other communities of Polk County.  Some of Mr. Moody’s honors, memberships, and associations include:

  • The Florida Bar Board Certification – Civil Trial Specialist
  • AV PREEMINENT Martindale-Hubbell Lawyer Ratings
  • Life-member Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum
  • Best Attorneys of America – Rue Rating Lifetime Charter Member
  • National Trial Lawyers: Top 100 Trial Lawyers

To schedule a free, no-obligation consultation, contact us online or call (863) 733-9090.

Contact Us Today



“Our experience with Moody Law has been awesome, from the first day of calling and talking with the front desk staff and meeting with everyone through the hold process, everyone has been helpful in helping us to resolve this matter.”

Rate, Review & Explore

Social Accounts Sprite
Google map image of our location in 575 N Broadway Ave  Bartow, FL

Bartow (next to courthouse)

575 N Broadway Ave
Bartow, FL 33830

Open Today 24 hours

Google map image of our location in 1905 U.S. 98  Lakeland, FL

Lakeland Office

1905 U.S. 98
Lakeland, FL 33801

Open Today 24 hours

What is the best time for you?

Add additional time

Which location would you prefer?

Tell us a bit about yourself...

(863) 733-9090 Send a message